Valhallians Team Captains
- 1969-1970: Brian Butters (1st year of club)
- 1970-1971: Brian Butters/Daryl Noullette
- 1971-1972: Brian Butters/Daryl Noullette
- 1972-1976: Mark Hume
- 1976-1977: John Carroll
- 1977-1978: Doug Branter
- 1978-1979: Mark Hume
- 1979-1981: Jon Hume
- 1981-1982: Paul Connolly
- 1982-1983: Matt Tippler
- 1983-1984: Bob McCliggott
- 1984-1986: Denis Crawford
- 1986-1987: Bob McCliggott
- 1987-1988: Mark Wyatt (Velox Valhallian merger)
- 1988-1989: Tim Sinclair
- 1989-1991: Mark Wyatt
- 1991-1993: Dewi Griffiths
- 1993-1994: Damon Jones/Dave Galbraith
- 1994-1996: Damon Jones
- 1996-1998: Jeff Constantinescu
- 1998-1999: Bruce Jordan
- 1999-2000: Todd Cunningham
- 2000-2001: Micha Seaberg
- 2001-2004: John Lyall
- 2004-2007: Mark Lawson
- 2007-2010: Murray Smith
- 2010-2011: Derek Pue/Eric Laptinsky
- 2011-2012: Eric Laptinsky
- 2012-2013: Phil Erb
- 2013-2014: Phil Erb/Dale Grimston
- 2014-2015: Connor Bottrell
- 2015-2016: Connor Bottrell/Jason Gagnier (Westshore re-location)
- 2016-2017: Matthew “Irish” Harland/David “Tito” Phillips
- 2017-2018: Clay Panga
- 2018-2020: Foster DeWitt
- 2020-2021: *No Season*
- 2021-2023: Aidan Holland
- 2023-2024: Braedan Bespalko